Nirmal Premkumar vs State 2024 INSC 193 – POCSO Accused Acquitted

Criminal Trial – Sexual Offences – Weight to be attached to the testimony of the victim in matters involving sexual offences where the prosecution’s case hinges on the victim’s evidence—in cases where witnesses are neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable, the Court should strive to find out the true genesis of the incident. The Court can rely on the victim as a “sterling witness” without further corroboration, but the quality and credibility must be exceptionally high. The statement of the prosecutrix ought to be consistent from the beginning to the end (minor inconsistences excepted), from the initial statement to the oral testimony, without creating any doubt qua the prosecution’s case. While a victim’s testimony is usually enough for sexual offence cases, an unreliable or insufficient account from the prosecutrix, marked by identified flaws and gaps, could make it difficult for a conviction to be recorded – Referred to Krishan Kumar Malik v. State of Haryana (2011) 7 SCC 130, Rai Sandeep v. State (NCT of Delhi)(2012) 8 SCC 21, Ganesan v. State (2020) 10 SCC 573. (Para 15) – When considering the evidence of a victim subjected to a sexual offence, the Court does not necessarily demand an almost accurate account of the incident. Instead, the emphasis is on allowing the victim to provide her version based on her recollection of events, to the extent reasonably possible for her to recollect. If the Court deems such evidence credible and free from doubt, there is hardly any insistence on corroboration of that version. However, an alleged offence of sexual harassment in a public place, as opposed to one committed within the confines of a room or a house, or even in a public place but away from the view of the public, stands on somewhat different premise. If any doubt arises in the Court’s mind regarding the veracity of the victim’s version, the Court may, at its discretion, seek corroboration from other witnesse s who directly observed the incident or from other attending circumstances to unearth the truth. (Para 17,18)

Summary: While setting aside concurrent conviction against two teachers, Supreme Court observed: Conviction undoubtedly can be recorded on the sole evidence of a victim of crime; however, it must undergo a strict scrutiny through the wellsettled legal principles as established by this Court in a catena of decisions. While the actions attributed to A-1, as sought to be demonstrated by the prosecution, may fall within the purview of ‘sexual harassment’ under section 11 of the POCSO Act, the evidence in this case has been marred by inadequacies from the outset, evident in contradictions within statements and testimonies- an act of sexual harassment of a girl student (who is also a minor) by any teacher would figure quite high in the list of offences of grave nature since it has far-reaching consequences, which impact more than just the parties to the proceeding. At the same time, it is axiomatic that reputation is earned by a teacher upon rendering service over the years and an accusation like the present would remain as an indelible mark marring his entire future life. Care has, therefore, to be taken so that his right to live a life of dignity and personal liberty are not put to jeopardy on the basis of half-baked evidence.

Read Judgment

Related Posts

105 thoughts on “Nirmal Premkumar vs State 2024 INSC 193 – POCSO Accused Acquitted”

  1. vmmqnxgiu

    Table of Contents All in all, Security Copilot agents can “really automate a lot of the repetitive tasks so the humans can focus on the strategic, truly critical work,” Li said. Heineken’s use of Aviatrix is helping the company make sense of its deep investments in cloud computing. Edwin Venhuizen, who acts as product owner connectivity at Heineken, described the situation in a statement: Table of Contents Place your wager in Aviatrix and prepare your aircraft for take-off or use the automatic play. You can halt the win multiplier at any time after it has begun and withdraw the existing reward. The prize you can win increases with the high of your trip! Overcome the limitations of native cloud provider security options with Aviatrix. Protect all of your data while improving network performance and operational costs.
    http://jobs.emiogp.com/author/hatalkcheland1977/
    Sign in to add this item to your wishlist, follow it, or mark it as ignored A: Yes, Space XY by BGaming Crash Game is compatible with both iOS and Android devices. This allows players to enjoy the game on their smartphones or tablets, making it easily accessible for on-the-go gaming. The top Space XY alternatives include:– Rocketman by Elbet– Rocket by DraftKings– Crash X by Turbo Games– Rocketon by Galaxsys – Cash or Crash by Funky Games Online Casino VS. Lotterie Games Bonus Round In Magic Mirror Copy and paste the HTML below into your website to make the above widget appear Space XY is simple yet rewarding in all areas. If it’s the fun aspect of gambling you are after, it offers that. Maybe you like the tension and thrill of not knowing what will happen next. The crash mechanism of Space XY introduces this to the game. And if you are searching for a game that rewards big, even from a small bet, you need not look further than Space XY. With a maximum multiplier of 10,000x your bet and a maximum bet limit of $100, you can rest assured that you will win big when you get lucky to hit the jackpot. Space XY has an RTP of between 96.88% and 98.92%.

  2. xccuowysd

    Although there is not much in it, it is the unpredictability of the JetX crash game that makes room for a thrilling gaming experience. Similar to many other online casino games, JetX’s algorithm is based on a random number generator. This means you won’t accurately know how high the rocket might fly. Here is how to implement the Martingale strategy to your play of Cbet JetX: JetX-Win is an informational website for entertainment and educational purposes only. Instead, it is advised to approach JetX with a prudent and knowledgeable attitude. Put your attention on comprehending the rules of the game, creating smart plans, and efficiently handling your bankroll. Accept the thrill of the game, but keep in mind that there are inherent hazards.Remember that JetX is intended to be fun, and while it is possible to make money, there is no surefire strategy or forecast that can ensure constant success. Enjoy the game for what it is—an thrilling and surprising gaming experience—by approaching it from a realistic angle.
    https://www.hoaxbuster.com/redacteur/tratasunly1982
    Step 1: Enter your Mobile Number (number must not be registered yet)Step 2: Enter Verification Code Step 3: Input the Referral CodeStep 4: After creating account, claim referral bonus to Lucknow Games Costumer Service.Step 5: Check your Account and Enjoy Lucknow Games Experience Happy Color will be a masterpiece of great art, and players will feel overwhelmed by what is in it. This is a new game, and players will have to color the pictures exactly what they had in mind. In this game, you can use coloring according to the picture or choose the color of your choice. The unique feature is that the game will continually add new pictures for you to choose from and unleash your passion. Become a painter with all the qualities and skills to create a vivid picture. Lucknow Games’ TRX Hash feature combines technology with games. TRON’s (TRX) blockchain technology ensures fair and transparent event results in these games. Participants can trust the gaming process by using TRX hash codes to verify game results’ integrity and randomness. Blockchain technology modernizes the event and adds excitement and reliability, making the “TRX Hash Win” a hit with tech-savvy visitors who like gaming and cutting-edge technology.

  3. fbpiqooau

    Copyright © 2014-2025 APKPure. Todos los derechos reservados. – Diviértase. Lucky Jet es un juego divertido y emocionante que puede ser disfrutado por jugadores de todos los niveles de experiencia. No te lo tomes demasiado en serio y disfruta del juego. APK Downloader – Extensión de Google Chrome Este juego de crash se distingue por protocolos de aleatorización verificados, asegurando resultados justos e impredecibles en cada ronda. La transparencia del sistema permite la verificación de resultados, fomentando la confianza entre aquellos que comienzan a jugar con dinero real. La plataforma LuckyJet 1win ofrece de manera consistente un rendimiento confiable en todos los dispositivos compatibles, lo que la hace accesible para diversas preferencias de jugadores. APKPure Lite – Una tienda de aplicaciones Android con una experiencia de página simple y eficiente. Descubre la aplicación que deseas de forma más fácil, rápida y segura.
    https://khadikapor.com/2025/06/03/balloon-game-app-tu-puerta-a-ingresos-desde-chile/
    Para retirar dinero de 1win a Nequi, simplemente accede a tu cuenta de 1win, selecciona Nequi como método de retiro, ingresa el monto y confirma la transacción. Lucky Jet 1win es un juego de azar, con los resultados de cada ronda determinados por un método aleatorio particular conocido como Provably Fair. Esto implica que no se puede pronosticar de ninguna manera. Sea cual sea la técnica que elija, no hay ninguna seguridad de que la siguiente ronda vaya a ir a su favor. Sin embargo, algunas estrategias importantes podrían mejorar su juego y le ayudarán a entender cómo ganar en Lucky Jet: Estos generosos bonos se acreditarán inmediatamente en su cuenta tras la confirmación. Recargue su depósito utilizando cualquier método de pago que le resulte conveniente en 1Win. Poner en práctica esta estrategia exige toda su atención durante el juego. La sincronización es crucial, ya que querrá identificar los momentos en los que se inician las rondas con altas probabilidades. En ese momento, deberá realizar ambas apuestas. Para la primera apuesta, establezca una retirada automática con un coeficiente de x2,0, mientras que cierre manualmente la segunda apuesta con un coeficiente que oscile entre x4 y x5. Incluso si la suerte no está de su lado y Lucky Joe despega prematuramente, la primera apuesta automática compensará la pérdida, proporcionando un colchón de protección.

  4. fyqppohna

    Plinko es solo uno de los cientos de juegos que podrían categorizarse como juegos de casino para móviles, porque no requiere ningún tipo de habilidad y es absolutamente de azar. Su popularidad ha llegado a través de vídeos de influencers, gamers y streamers en publicaciones que son claramente contenido patrocinado camuflado como vídeos realizados por iniciativa propia. Lo cierto es que varios blogs explican que es un fraude en el que no se puede retirar el dinero que ganas, sino que la aplicación se queda los datos del usuario. En el caso de los juegos que usen la tecnología de retransmisión en la nube, se puede descargar un aplicación de inicio o una versión de prueba gratuitas. En el caso de los jugadores con dispositivos iOS, la mejor forma de jugar es a través de la versión móvil de la plataforma. Para tenerla siempre al alcance de un toque, puedes agregar la aplicación PWA a tu pantalla de inicio. Solo debes desplegar el menú de tu navegador y seleccionar la opción “Agregar a inicio”.
    https://apple.xn--soportetcnicobogota-izb.com/review-del-juego-balloon-de-smartsoft-para-jugadores-de-peru/
    Synduality: Echo of Ada es un videojuego de acción y disparos en tercera persona de ciencia ficción ambientado en el año 2222 a cargo de Game Studio y Bandai Namco Entertainment para PC, PlayStation 5 y Xbox Series en el que los jugadores se convertirán en nómadas para enfrentarse a unas criaturas xenomórficas conocidas como enders’, así como a los nómadas de otros jugadores, con la ayuda de inteligencias artificiales aliadas, los magi, que los guiarán en su viaje. Yasha: Legends of the Demon Blade es un videojuego de acción RPG a cargo de 7QUARK y Game Source Entertainment para PC, Switch, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5 y Xbox Series. Derrota a fuerzas malévolas en este impresionante mundo roguelite de inspiración japonesa. Conviértete en un maestro de las Demon Blades y lucha contra enjambres de demonios en un reino de fantasía ambientado en el período Edo. A lo largo de cada viaje, descubrirás las verdades ocultas que se esconden en tiempos difíciles.

  102. Noble

    I am extremely inspired together with your writing skills and also with the layout to your weblog. Is this a paid subject or did you customize it yourself? Either way stay up the nice quality writing, it’s rare to see a great weblog like this one today. I like citecase.in ! I made: Blaze AI

  103. Krissy

    I’m extremely inspired together with your writing abilities as smartly as with the structure for your weblog. Is that this a paid subject matter or did you modify it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it’s uncommon to see a great weblog like this one nowadays. I like citecase.in ! I made: Beacons AI

  104. code of destiny

    Hey there! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying
    to get my blog to rank for some targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very good success.
    If you know of any please share. Thank you! I saw
    similar blog here: COD

  105. Shavonne

    Hello! Do you know if they make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization? I’m trying to get my site to rank for some targeted
    keywords but I’m not seeing very good gains. If you know of any please share.
    Kudos! I saw similar article here: Eco product

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *