Bihar City Manager Cadre (Appointment and Service Conditions) Rules, 2014 -A conjoint reading of the Rules, 2014 in particular rules 5 and 11, with the advertisement and giving it a pragmatic and harmonious construction, what emerges is that 32% in the written examination would make a candidate eligible and qualified to be placed in the consideration zone. [In this case, candidate received 22.5 marks out of 70, 32.14 per cent, above the minimum qualifying marks of 32 per cent as per the advertisement, the Court held that the Commission was not right by denying her a place on the merit list.]